American Federal Rare Coin & Bullion
4
The rst sign your dealer is lying to you is if your dealer shows you charts, graphs or statics comparing coin prices in the 1970’s with today’s prices, don’t walk away, RUN!!
This is a manipulation of data and an extreme distortion of facts. Any dealer who uses grading comparisons from 1970 is outright misrepresenting the coin market. Standards used today cannot be compared to the 1970’s. In fact many of the grades used today did not even exist in the 70’s. Plus, today’s grading standards are much stricter than what was acceptable prior to 1986.
In fact an MS-65 in 1970 would most likely only be considered an MS-
63 or LESS today. This difference in grading can result in a substantial difference in price. For example a $2½ Indian Gold piece is worth $715
in MS-63 and $2000 in MS-65. Therefore, it is misleading to suggest an MS-65 coin purchased in the 70’s is now worth $2000 when it’s most
likely only worth $715 or LESS.It’s bad enough that every dealer knows this fact. The worst part is that the dealers use this as a way to avoid repurchasing coins yet use these misleading charts to make the claim of rare coins’ performance. The only truthful charts begin at 1986 or later. No surprise, these tell a completely different story. In fact the
Coin Dealer Newsletter
only charts from 1990 to present. These charts clearly show that rare coin market as a whole is worth LESS today than in 1990. Not surprisingly, even the best performering sectors are only up 20% since 1990! Add the dealer
markups and the prot disappearsThe charts and statistics most dealers share do not include the mark-
ups, fees and actual prices charged. They are comparing only “bid” to “bid” prices. In reality a coin you pay $1500 for is probably “bid” at only
$1000. So if you’re extremely lucky and that coin doubles - you would only realized a 33% prot. Plus most dealers want to make 10% to 20%